Texas Megachurch Battles Methodist Denomination Over Church Name and Control

Texas Megachurch Battles Methodist Denomination Over Church Name and Control

CNIR | DOMESTIC CHRISTIAN NEWS | CHURCH & LEGAL AFFAIRS

One of America’s largest Methodist congregations is challenging its former denomination in court after members voted overwhelmingly to separate, raising questions about church identity, property rights, and religious authority.

By CNIR News Desk | November 16, 2026

Texas Megachurch Takes Its Former Denomination to Court

A major Texas Methodist congregation has intensified its legal confrontation with the United Methodist Church (UMC), asking a court to prevent denominational officials from using the name associated with its historic Dallas ministry.

Highland Park Methodist Church filed a request for a temporary restraining order on November 10, arguing that the denomination’s Horizon Texas Conference is improperly using the congregation’s former name, Highland Park United Methodist Church.

The latest legal action follows an overwhelming congregational vote in October to separate from the denomination.

Church leaders contend that continued use of the historic name by denominational representatives has created confusion among worshippers, donors, and the surrounding community.

The dispute has developed into a broader confrontation over congregational independence, denominational authority, and the legal identity of a church established more than a century ago.

More Than 90 Percent Vote to Leave the Denomination

Highland Park Methodist Church announced that 90.35% of the 4,775 ballots cast supported withdrawing from the United Methodist Church.

The congregation subsequently continued worship services under the name Highland Park Methodist Church at its longtime property near Hillcrest Road and Mockingbird Lane in Dallas.

However, Bishop Ruben Saenz Jr., who oversees the Horizon Texas Conference, rejected the validity of the vote.

Denominational officials maintain that the congregation cannot unilaterally terminate its relationship with the UMC through a local membership vote.

The conference has continued recognizing a congregation under the Highland Park United Methodist Church name, with the Rev. Andy Lewis appointed as its pastor.

Meanwhile, the departing congregation continues to recognize the Rev. Matt Tuggle as its senior minister.

The competing claims have left two groups asserting different understandings of the historic congregation’s identity and future.

A Legal Battle Over More Than a Church Name

The disagreement began before the October separation vote.

In August 2026, the Horizon Texas Conference filed a lawsuit challenging changes Highland Park made to its governing documents in 2022.

The conference alleged that the revisions removed references to the United Methodist Church and eliminated important denominational oversight provisions.

It also questioned whether the changes improperly reduced congregational participation in major church decisions.

Highland Park leaders dispute those allegations, maintaining that the revisions complied with Texas law and that the conference had knowledge of the changes.

The church also argues that its governing structure was established through earlier procedures and that it continued participating in denominational activities after the revisions.

The original lawsuit involving church governance and property remains unresolved.

A non-jury trial has been scheduled for October 2027.

Former President George W. Bush Supports Congregation

The dispute has attracted national attention partly because former President George W. Bush and former First Lady Laura Bush have longstanding connections to Highland Park.

The couple, who have attended the congregation for decades, reportedly participated in the October vote supporting separation from the denomination.

A spokesperson for the former president also expressed appreciation for Pastor Matt Tuggle’s leadership during the dispute.

Highland Park has historically ranked among the largest congregations in the United Methodist Church, with approximately 15,000 members reported in recent denominational statistics.

Its prominence makes the dispute particularly significant within American Methodism.

Why Methodist Churches Are Dividing

The Highland Park controversy comes amid years of denominational conflict involving theology, church governance, and differing interpretations of Christian teaching.

Thousands of congregations previously departed the United Methodist Church following disagreements over LGBTQ-related policies, including same-sex marriage and clergy ordination.

The denomination changed several of its policies at its 2024 General Conference.

However, the Highland Park legal dispute centers specifically on governance documents, denominational authority, congregational decision-making, and property rights.

Although broader theological divisions provide important context, the current litigation should not be reduced to a disagreement over sexuality or marriage.

Both sides have presented competing legal and organizational arguments concerning the congregation’s relationship with the denomination.

Who Has the Final Authority Over a Local Church?

The controversy raises an important question extending beyond the Methodist denomination:

When a congregation votes to leave its denomination, who ultimately controls its name, property, leadership, and religious identity?

United Methodist governance operates through a connectional structure in which local congregations participate in a broader system of conferences, bishops, and denominational rules.

Highland Park’s leadership argues that its congregation possesses legal rights that protect its organizational identity and governing decisions.

The Horizon Texas Conference maintains that denominational obligations cannot simply be eliminated through unilateral changes to local church documents.

Civil courts must consider applicable law while respecting constitutional protections that limit government involvement in religious doctrine and internal ecclesiastical decisions.

The outcome could have implications for other congregations navigating disagreements with their denominations, although its legal significance will depend on the court’s eventual rulings.

What Happens Next?

Highland Park Methodist Church is seeking judicial intervention to prevent continued use of its former name by the denomination’s recognized congregation.

The Horizon Texas Conference continues to maintain that Highland Park United Methodist Church remains part of the denomination.

Meanwhile, the underlying dispute over church governance and property is moving toward further litigation.

For thousands of church members, the controversy involves more than a legal name.

It concerns the congregation’s future leadership, religious affiliation, and the authority to determine its institutional direction.

The central question is whether Highland Park’s overwhelming membership vote will ultimately establish its independence or whether denominational governance rules will prevail in court.

Until the legal proceedings are resolved, both sides remain divided over the future of one of Texas’s most prominent Methodist congregations.

Reporting references: Religion News Service, November 16, 2026; FOX 4 Dallas, November 12, 2026; The Christian Post, November 16, 2026; D Magazine, August 26, 2026. Religion News +3


CNIR Editorial Disclaimer

Christian News & Investigative Reports (CNIR) presents this article for informational, educational, and public-interest purposes. The report is based on publicly available news coverage, statements from the parties, and descriptions of ongoing legal proceedings. Allegations made in litigation are disputed claims and should not be interpreted as established judicial findings. CNIR does not endorse either party’s legal position and remains committed to accuracy, fairness, and responsible journalism.

Christian News & Investigative Reports (CNIR)

Reporting the headline. Investigating the facts.

cnirbc.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *